Where to Buy Organic Turkey: The Top Retailers and Online Options

Organic turkey offers a natural, wholesome alternative to conventionally raised birds Free of antibiotics, hormones, and GMOs, organic turkeys are raised on organic feed in humane environments. Their meat is beautifully lean and flavorful.

But where can you find high-quality organic turkey for your holiday meals or family dinners? Here are the best places to buy organic turkey, from national chains to direct from family farms.

Buying Organic Turkey at Grocery Stores

Many major supermarkets now carry some selection of organic turkey products:

• Whole Foods – Offers fresh and frozen organic whole turkeys, breasts, cutlets, sausage, deli meat.
• Kroger – Simple Truth brand organic turkey options including whole birds, breasts, and ground.
• Publix – Publix GreenWise brand fresh and frozen organic turkey.
• Safeway – O Organics label organic whole turkey and boneless breasts.
• Albertsons – Open Nature organic whole turkey, breasts, cutlets, sausage.
• Wegmans – Organic whole turkeys, boneless breasts, ground turkey.

The benefit of grocery stores is convenience. However, selection of organic turkey sizes, types, and brands may be more limited than online or direct from farms.

Ordering Organic Turkey Online

For wider selection of premium organic turkey from top brands, online shopping is ideal:

• Mary’s Organic – Offers diverse organic turkey options including heritage breeds.
• Cascadian Farm – Whole organic turkeys and boneless breasts.
• Applegate – Organic turkey burgers, hot dogs, sausage and deli meat.
• Jennie-O Organic – Whole turkeys, boneless breasts, ground and cutlets.
• Eberly Organic – Heirloom breed whole turkeys and roasts.
• Diestel Family Ranch – Organic whole turkey, breasts, deli meat.

Online shopping for organic turkey provides more choices in breeds, sizes, cuts, and specialty products. You can order exactly what you need and have it shipped directly to your door.

Purchasing Directly from Organic Farms

For the true farm-to-table experience, consider buying organic turkey directly from family farms. Two top organic turkey producers that ship nationwide include:

• Mary’s Free Range Turkeys – Organic and heritage breed turkeys raised on sustainable family farms.
• Organic Prairie – Cooperative of family farms offering organic whole turkey and cuts.

When you buy direct, you know you’re getting authentic, humanely raised organic turkey, potentially at lower cost by cutting out retail markups. However, minimum orders or shipping fees may apply.

What Size Organic Turkey Should You Buy?

Allow about 1⁄3 to 1⁄2 pound of turkey per person when estimating what size organic turkey to purchase. Leftovers are great for sandwiches or casseroles. Here are some common organic turkey sizes:

• Small gatherings – 8-12 lb whole turkey or 2.5-3 lb breast.
• Medium gatherings – 12-16 lb whole turkey or 4-7 lb breast.
• Large gatherings – 16-22 lb whole turkey.
• Just breasts – Get boneless breasts from 2-7 lbs.

Be sure to order your desired size and type of organic turkey well ahead of the holidays when demand is highest.

How Much Does Organic Turkey Cost?

Due to the higher cost of organic feed and requirements for humane raising, organic turkey costs more than conventional turkey. Some average prices:

• Organic whole turkeys range $3.49 to $6.99 per lb
• Organic turkey breasts average $7.99 to $11.99 per lb
• Organic deli meat and sausage run $6.99 to $14.99 per lb

So you can expect to spend $60 and up for a small organic turkey, over $100 for a large bird feeding a crowd. Going direct to family farms can provide savings.

Tips for Choosing Your Organic Turkey

Follow these tips for picking the perfect organic turkey:

• Select heritage or heirloom breeds for premium flavor and texture.
• Check labels for certifications like USDA Organic and Animal Welfare Approved.
• Choose kosher or halal organic turkey if you require them.
• Order early for holidays – organic turkeys sell out quickly.
• Inspect packaging condition and freshness/freeze by dates.
• Allow time to thaw frozen organic turkeys in the fridge.

Popular Brands of Organic Turkey

If you’re new to organic turkey, sticking with a well-known national brand can provide confidence in quality. Top organic turkey brands include:

• Mary’s Organic – Family-owned for decades and specialists in organic.
• Jennie-O Organic – Leading brand for organic turkey products.
• Cascadian Farm Organic – Owned by General Mills, common in stores.
• Applegate Organic – Focus on organic and natural prepared turkey products.
• Nature’s Promise – Costco’s reputable house brand of organic turkey.
• Simple Truth Organic – Kroger’s highly affordable organic brand.

There are also smaller organic turkey farms like Eberly, Diestel, and Organic Prairie with exceptional quality and standards.

Enjoy the Healthy, Humane Benefits

When you serve organic turkey, you can feel good knowing the turkey lived a healthy, low-stress life with no antibiotics or GMOs. With so many great organic turkey options now available, going organic for your holiday or family meals is easier than ever. Just order your premium organic turkey in time and get ready to enjoy naturally delicious flavor.