Fall-off-the-bone pulled turkey slow-cooked in a Dutch oven. Shredded turkey thigh that is tender and full of flavor served in a tasty sauce. This is a lighter version of a favorite dish.
Want some pulled pork but want to eat better? This amazing recipe for pulled turkey is the answer. Just as delicious and comforting but a bit better for your health. This simple recipe is excellent for a less traditional, no-fuss Thanksgiving dinner.
But not only. I also make this pulled turkey recipe all through the year whenever my kids ask for it again. Learn How to Cook Turkey Legs (in the Oven) or look at the Oven-Roasted Turkey Thigh (with Potatoes) for more turkey thigh ideas.
Check out the Dutch Oven Turkey or this beautiful Red Wine Turkey if you want to make a whole turkey for Thanksgiving. Or make Slow Cooker Turkey. [feast_advanced_jump_to].
Shredding Turkey for Tasty Meals: A How-To Guide
With its lean protein and versatility, cooked turkey makes a terrific addition to soups, salads, sandwiches, and more. While you can dice or chop turkey, shredding the meat creates delicious, stringy strands with lots of surface area to soak up flavors. But can you actually shred a turkey efficiently at home? The answer is a resounding yes! With the right techniques and tools, it’s easy to shred turkey for tacos, casseroles, barbecue, and any dish calling for pulled meat.
Choosing the Right Turkey for Shredding
You can shred a whole roasted turkey or just parts like breast, thighs, drumsticks, or wings. The optimal turkey for shredding will be:
-
Fully cooked until well-done and the juices run clear Undercooked meat resists shredding,
-
Allowed to rest after cooking so juices redistribute evenly
-
Cooled somewhat after cooking so it’s easier to handle.
-
Moist and tender with connective tissue fully broken down. Overcooked dry meat also resists shredding.
Turkey breast is a prime choice since it naturally cooks up tender and lean. Just avoid any with bones still in. Opt for boneless turkey breast roasted or smoked until very tender when pierced. Dark meat like thighs and legs works too, as the collagen melts into succulent strands. The cooked skin can also be shredded along with the meat for added moisture and flavor.
Chilling or partially freezing the cooked turkey for 30-60 minutes firms it up for better shredding. Just avoid fully frozen turkey, as that makes for a stringy, mushy texture when shredded.
Hand Shredding Turkey
No special equipment required! With your (clean) hands, you can simply pull cooked turkey into stringy strands. Here are some tips:
-
Use forks to initially pull turkey chunks away from bones, if using bone-in pieces like breast or thighs. Discard bones.
-
Pull the turkey meat into large chunks, discarding any excess fat or skin if desired.
-
Using your fingers, break up and shred the turkey chunks into fine fibers pulling with the grain.
-
Stop frequently to scrape shreds off your hands back into the bowl until turkey is fully shredded and strings apart easily.
Hand shredding gives you maximum control over the size of shreds. Just be sure to wear gloves or wash hands very well both before and after.
Shredding Turkey With Forks
Two forks can also do the trick for shredding. Simply:
-
Hold a fork in each hand with the tongs facing down.
-
Stab into the turkey meat with the left fork to hold it steady.
-
Use the right fork to pull slices or chunks of turkey away, shredding it downward.
-
Rotate and turn the turkey pieces for even shredding on all sides.
Dual forks shred turkey rapidly into the ideal thin, stringy texture for fillings and toppings. It just takes some practice controlling the turkey and pulling in the right direction with the forks.
Shredding Turkey With Kitchen Tools
Several standard kitchen tools can speed up turkey shredding without requiring special equipment:
-
Electric mixer – Attach the paddle attachment and mix cooked turkey on low/medium speed to get finely shredded meat.
-
Stand mixer – Use the paddle beater for pulled turkey. The bowl catches all the shreds neatly.
-
Food processor – Pulse in batches for perfectly even shredding in seconds.
-
Meat grinder – Grind turkey through the finest die for thin, stringy shreds.
-
Potato masher – Mash and shred meat between grid holes.
-
Wire whisk – Pull strands of turkey through the loops with a gentle lifting and turning motion.
Any appliance with blades or mesh grids makes swift work of shredding. Just avoid over-processing to a paste.
Power Tools Designed for Shredding
If you plan to shred turkey regularly, a tool designed specifically for shredding and pulling meats offers great convenience:
-
Electric meat shredder – Rotating blades quickly shred meats hands-free.
-
Stand mixer shredder attachment – Easily fits many stand mixer brands for power shredding.
-
Claw meat puller – Grab and pull meats effortlessly into smooth shreds.
-
Bear claws – These heavy duty meat shredding claws securely grip and tear meats.
-
Twin blade meat shredder – Dual stainless steel blades mounted in a sturdy handle shred with a squeeze.
While pricier, these make child’s play of getting the ideal pulled turkey texture in large quantities.
Storing and Using Shredded Turkey
Properly stored, shredded turkey keeps for 3-4 days refrigerated or 2-3 months frozen. To maximize freshness:
-
Let turkey cool before shredding to avoid excess moisture from condensation.
-
Spread shredded turkey on a baking sheet before refrigerating so it doesn’t clump.
-
Use freezer-safe containers or bags for long-term frozen storage.
-
Avoid repeated thawing and refreezing shredded turkey.
Add shredded turkey to:
-
Tacos, burritos, enchiladas, and other Mexican dishes
-
Barbecue sandwiches with coleslaw
-
Turkey salad with cranberries and pecans
-
Hearty soups, chilis, and stews
-
Casseroles and pot pies
-
Pizza, wraps, and sandwiches
-
Omelets, scrambles, and breakfast tacos
With the right turkey and a little elbow grease, you can easily shred meat for versatile meals. Dive into this tasty cooking technique to take your turkey dishes to the next level!
How to make pulled turkey in the oven?
Preparations:
- Preheat the oven.
- Mix the spices in a small bowl.
- Remove the skin from the turkey thigh.
- Rub the meat with the seasoning mixture.
- Chop the onion.
- Mix the sauce ingredients in a separate bowl.
Assemble:
- Distribute the onion in the pot (1).
- Place the seasoned thigh on top of the onions (2).
- Pour the sauce on top of the piece (3).
- Cover with the lid.
Slow-cook in the oven:
- Place the pot in the preheated oven.
- Allow 3 to 4 hours to cook. The exact time will depend on your oven, as some are hotter than others.
- Be sure to check the meat. It should be very soft and easy to pull off the bone with a fork. If it’s not there yet, wait half an hour more and check again.
- You won’t need a meat thermometer to tell if the meat is done this time; it’s very clear.
Shred:
- Shred the meat with two forks (5).
- Put it back in the pot with the sauce and mix it all together. Reheat shortly if necessary (6).
If you have time, marinate the thigh for up to 24 hours. This will give the flavors more time to work their way into the turkey meat, making it taste even better. Rub it well with the spices, wrap it in plastic, and refrigerate it. Taking the thigh out of the fridge and letting it come to room temperature for an hour before cooking
Make in advance: Cook the dish. Let it cool completely and refrigerate it until ready to serve. Reheat on the stovetop, often stirring.
The same as pulled pork, which is meat slowly cooked until falling apart.
Technically, yes. However, I don’t really recommend it. Dark meat is a bit fattier than white, and fat moistens the meat and enhances the flavor. Most of the fat is under the skin, which you will already remove. What’s left will keep the thigh moist and make it taste great. Don’t want to cook lean meat? Try this simple recipe for boneless, skinless turkey breast or this one for juicy Dutch oven turkey breast.
Definitely. Set the thigh on low heat and cook it for 5 to 6 hours, or until you can easily pull the meat off the bone.
Refrigerate leftovers in an airtight container for 3-4 days. Freeze in a freezer container for up to 3 months. Defrost in the refrigerator and reheat before serving. Reheat the sauce in the microwave or on the stovetop. You can also refrigerate or freeze the leftover meat separated from the sauce. You can use these leftovers for making Turkey Pot Pie with Puff Pastry.
- Most people like to put pulled turkey in hamburger buns, make sliders, or put it on a sandwich. It’s tasty and messy, but you can serve these tender meat pieces in other ways. Top the meat with Coleslaw for Burgers.
- Meat and sauce on top of creamy mashed potatoes is my favorite way to eat it. It’s the best comfort food.
- Any way you cook the potatoes goes well with the meat. You can also serve it with rice or creamy polenta. Mix the saucy meat with cooked pasta.
- This can be made if you keep some of the meat separate from the sauce:
More Thanksgiving turkey dinner ideas
How do you shred a turkey by hand?
FAQ
Is turkey good for shredding?
Can you shred turkey in a blender?
How long is shredded turkey good for?