Why Are My Chicken and Dumplings Tough and How Can I Fix It?
Chicken and dumplings is a beloved comfort food, but it can be frustrating when your homemade version turns out tough and chewy instead of tender and fluffy. Don’t ditch this classic dish just yet! With a few simple tweaks, you can get your chicken and dumplings texture just right.
In this article we’ll explore the common culprits behind tough chicken and dumplings and provide actionable solutions to help you achieve pillowy perfection. Read on to become a chicken and dumplings master!
What Causes Tough Chicken and Dumplings?
There are a few key reasons your chicken and dumplings may turn out dense and chewy rather than light and tender:
-
Overworking the dough – Kneading the dumpling dough too much develops gluten, leading to a tougher texture. Handle the dough gently.
-
Using the wrong flour – All-purpose flour lends the best texture. Avoid bread or whole wheat flours, which can make dense dumplings.
-
Undercooking – Dumplings need ample steaming time to become tender. Ensure they cook through completely.
-
Overcrowding – Too many dumplings in the pot prevents proper cooking. Give them breathing room.
-
High heat – Rapid boiling can make dumplings tough. Keep the broth at a gentle simmer.
-
Overstirring – Excess stirring while cooking agitates the dumplings, leading to a chewy texture.
Follow our handy tips below to troubleshoot each potential issue and end up with perfect dumplings every time.
Tips for Tender Chicken and Dumplings
- Handle the dough gently.
-
Mix the dumpling dough just until combined – no vigorous kneading required.
-
When shaping dumplings, use a light touch to avoid overworking the dough.
- Use the right flour.
-
All-purpose flour lends the ideal texture. Measure accurately.
-
Avoid bread or whole wheat flours, which contain more gluten.
- Don’t skimp on cooking time.
-
Ensure dumplings steam for 15-20 minutes once added to the broth.
-
Resist lifting the lid too often to allow them to cook through.
- Give dumplings breathing room.
-
Arrange dumplings in a single layer on top of the broth.
-
Overcrowding prevents proper steaming and texture development.
- Maintain a gentle simmer.
-
If broth is rapidly boiling, turn down heat to a gentle simmer.
-
High heat can make dumplings dense and chewy.
- Stir minimally after adding dumplings.
-
Once added to broth, avoid excess stirring.
-
Gentle stirring just 2-3 times is sufficient.
Advanced Tips and Tricks
-
Use cold butter in the dough for extra flakiness.
-
Add a couple tablespoons of heavy cream to the dough for extra richness.
-
Opt for rolled dumplings over drop dumplings for a more delicate texture.
-
Bake pre-shaped raw dumplings before adding to broth for an even lighter result.
-
Dust dumplings with flour after shaping to prevent sticking.
-
Use homemade chicken stock in place of water for maximum flavor.
-
Adjust broth thickness with a roux or cornstarch slurry if too thin.
Putting It All Together
Follow these simple guidelines for pillowy perfection:
-
Handle dough gently
-
Use all-purpose flour
-
Allow ample steam time
-
Avoid overcrowding
-
Maintain a gentle simmer
-
Stir dumplings minimally once added
With the proper techniques and a few easy tweaks to your recipe, you can transform your dense, chewy chicken and dumplings into the tender, comforting dish you crave. Ditch the dumpling disasters for good! Now you have all the secrets to create this beloved one-pot meal just like grandma used to make.
Why are my chicken and dumplings hard or tough?
When making authentic Chicken and Dumplings, there are two things to consider that will ensure you do not end up with hard or tough dumplings:
- Stir, spoon, and level! When it is time measure out your 2 cups of all-purpose flour, be sure to stir the flour with a fork, then spoon the flour into a dry-measure measuring cup, and level off.
- Substitute in self-rising flour for lighter fluffier dumplings! All-purpose flour produces a thick, dense dumpling that has an almost al dente pasta texture. That being said, if you like lighter, fluffier dumplings, you can use self-rising flour instead. The denser, all-purpose-flour-based dumplings are what I’m used to, and I find them much easier to work with when rolling them out and cutting them. The self-rising flour ones also tend to break up in the stock if they’re stirred too much. But, it’s really up to you and your texture preferences.
What is the secret to perfect dumplings?
Okay, buckle-up because there is a good bit to cover here… many many factors are at play when it comes to perfecting the best dumplings. Here are a few of my best tips and tricks:
- Pay attention to your stock! Over the years, I’ve learned that nothing is more important about chicken and dumplings than getting your stock right. It’s got to have that super rich flavor and velvety texture. To do that, I start with a whole young chicken. The bones help richen the broth, so I always use a whole chicken. Opting for a young chicken means the meat will be super tender and since they’re smaller, they’ll cooker faster.
- Don’t skimp on the seasonings! I like to really get the flavors going by using 1 heaping tablespoon of a wet chicken base like Better Than Bouillon. If you don’t have that, 3 chicken bouillon cubes will work as well. And as one final punch of flavor, I add a can of cream of chicken soup. This step is certainly optional, but highly recommended. It helps to thicken the stock some and adds some great flavor.
- Use a cornstarch slurry! I like for my stock to be a little thick, so I add a cornstarch slurry to thicken it up a bit. This step is optional, but I do recommend it. Simply whisk 3 tablespoons of cornstarch into about 1/4 cup of cool water, and then whisk that into the stock. When you bring the stock to a boil, it will thicken up and give it a velvety texture.
Chicken N’ Dumplings My Great Granny Style Old School Chicken And Dumplings | Roll Out Dumplings
FAQ
Why are my dumplings tough and chewy?
If you overwork your dumpling dough, you’ll end up with overly chewy and tough dumplings, and no one wants that. It’s similar to how, if you over-knead a loaf of homemade bread, you’ll end up with a hard loaf.
How do you keep dumplings from getting tough?
Cold butter or margarine is cut into the flour mixture to bind the dry ingredients together. It also keeps the dumplings light and tender.
How to make dumplings not chewy?
Don’t Overwork the Dumpling Dough
Stir everything together until the wet and dry ingredients are combined and you don’t see any more dry flour. The dough might look a little lumpy, but that’s okay! Overworking the dough is one of the easiest ways to end up with tough dumplings.
Why did my dumplings come out hard?
The trickiest part of the dumplings remaining fluffy lies with the cooking time. If the dumplings are cooked for too long, then they will become hard. If they are cooked and allowed to remain in the heated environment — in the hot liquid or covered in the hot pot, then the dumpling will contract and get hard.