Which Chicken Pizza is Best in Domino’s? The Ultimate Flavor Showdown

Have you ever stood there, staring at the Domino’s menu, feeling completely overwhelmed by all the chicken pizza options? I feel your pain! As someone who’s ordered way too many Domino’s pizzas over the years (my wallet is crying), I’ve made it my personal mission to find out which chicken pizza at Domino’s truly deserves your hard-earned cash.

After countless pizza nights and analyzing opinions from pizza enthusiasts across the web I’m ready to share the definitive ranking of Domino’s chicken pizzas. Whether you’re planning a game day feast or just a lazy Friday night in, this guide will help you choose the perfect chicken pizza for your taste buds.

The Chicken Pizza Contenders at Domino’s

Before we dive into the rankings, let’s meet our delicious contestants. Domino’s offers several chicken-topped pizzas that have gained loyal followings

• Buffalo Chicken Pizza
• Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza
• Memphis BBQ Chicken Pizza
• Chicken Taco Pizza
• Specialty Chicken (technically not a pizza, but worth mentioning)

Each one brings something unique to the table, with different sauces, cheese combinations, and complementary toppings. But which one reigns supreme? Let’s find out!

The Rankings: From Good to Mind-Blowing

4. Chicken Taco Pizza

Starting at the bottom of our list (though still tasty) is the Chicken Taco Pizza. This creation attempts to combine two beloved foods into one with mixed results.

What’s on it:

• Traditional pizza sauce mixed with taco seasonings
• Grilled chicken
• Fresh tomatoes
• Green peppers
• Onions
• Cheese blend

The verdict: While the concept is creative, the execution doesn’t quite capture the essence of either a great taco or a great pizza. The taco-seasoned sauce is interesting but can sometimes taste a bit confused. It’s not bad by any means, but compared to the other chicken options, it lacks that wow factor.

As one pizza lover commented, “It’s not a taco, but it’s a tasty option worth trying at least once.” You can customize it with jalapeños for extra kick, but even then, the other chicken pizzas outshine this one.

3. Memphis BBQ Chicken Pizza

Moving up the ranks, we have the Memphis BBQ Chicken Pizza, which has developed quite a following among BBQ enthusiasts.

What’s on it:

• BBQ sauce (instead of traditional red sauce)
• Grilled chicken breast
• Crunchy onions
• A blend of provolone, mozzarella, and cheddar cheeses

The verdict: This pizza delivers that sweet and tangy BBQ flavor that many people crave. The combination of the sauce with the cheesy goodness creates a satisfying balance. The onions add a nice crunch to contrast with the tender chicken.

According to pizza experts, “The Memphis BBQ chicken pizza is one of the most popular, and for a good reason. It combines that delicious BBQ chicken flavor with one of the world’s most beloved foods, pizza.”

While it’s a solid choice, especially for BBQ lovers, it doesn’t quite reach the heights of our top two contenders.

2. Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza

Narrowly missing the top spot is the Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza, a decadent creation that’s basically comfort food in pizza form.

What’s on it:

• Ranch sauce (instead of tomato sauce)
• Grilled chicken breast
• Crispy bacon
• Diced tomatoes
• Mozzarella and provolone cheeses

The verdict: This pizza is a flavor bomb that combines the universally loved combo of chicken, bacon, and ranch. The ranch sauce base provides a creamy, tangy foundation that complements the savory chicken and bacon perfectly. The diced tomatoes add a fresh element that cuts through the richness.

Many fans say it tastes like “everything you love about a chicken bacon ranch sandwich but on a pizza.” The only reason it doesn’t take the #1 spot is that some find it a bit too rich to eat regularly. But for an occasional indulgence, it’s hard to beat.

1. Buffalo Chicken Pizza – THE CHAMPION!

Taking the crown as the best chicken pizza at Domino’s is the Buffalo Chicken Pizza, a spicy, tangy masterpiece that consistently earns rave reviews.

What’s on it:

• Buffalo sauce (replacing the tomato sauce)
• Grilled chicken breast
• American, cheddar, and provolone cheeses
• Diced onions
• Extra buffalo sauce drizzled on top

The verdict: This pizza hits all the right notes for chicken wing lovers. The buffalo sauce provides just enough heat without being overwhelming, and the combination of three cheeses creates the perfect creamy counterbalance to the spice. It ranks #2 in overall Domino’s pizzas according to customer reviews, making it their top chicken option.

As one enthusiastic Redditor put it, “The buffalo chicken pizza is amazing it’s spicy, but not intolerable.” Another fan described it as “probably the best pizza we got.”

What makes this pizza special is how it captures the essence of buffalo wings while still being distinctly pizza-like. The multiple cheese blend and the double dose of buffalo sauce (both as the base and drizzled on top) create layers of flavor that keep you coming back for more.

Honorable Mention: Domino’s Specialty Chicken

While not technically a pizza, I’d be remiss not to mention Domino’s Specialty Chicken in this discussion. This unique menu item consists of 12 breaded chicken pieces topped with sauce, cheese, and various toppings, somewhat resembling a deconstructed chicken pizza.

Available in flavors like Spicy Jalapeño-Pineapple, Classic Hot Buffalo, Sweet BBQ Bacon, and Crispy Bacon & Tomato, this dish provides another way to satisfy your chicken and cheese cravings.

One reviewer from MassLive described it as “an unholy mess of chicken, cheese and toppings that fall everywhere as you pull off pieces to eat like a cheesy-chicken monkey bread. It’s a little scary, but in a good way.”

Among the Specialty Chicken varieties, the Spicy Jalapeño-Pineapple was surprisingly rated the best, with the reviewer noting: “The Spicy Jalapeno-Pineapple is by far the lightest offering of the Specialty Chicken bunch and is easily the best. The jalapeno’s not too hot, and the pineapply glaze isn’t overly sweet.”

Tips for Ordering the Perfect Domino’s Chicken Pizza

After all this research, I’ve picked up some pro tips to make your Domino’s chicken pizza experience even better:

1. Consider your crust: The Buffalo Chicken works well on any crust, but many fans prefer it on the hand-tossed option. The Memphis BBQ is excellent Brooklyn style or on thin crust.

2. Don’t forget the dips: Garlic dipping sauce pairs wonderfully with the Buffalo Chicken pizza, while extra ranch is a must for the Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch.

3. Customization is key: Add jalapeños to the Buffalo Chicken for extra heat, or switch the Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch to garlic parmesan sauce instead of ranch for a different flavor profile.

4. Order time matters: These pizzas are best enjoyed fresh and hot. The Buffalo Chicken, in particular, can lose some of its appeal as it cools.

The Final Verdict

While taste is subjective, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza stands out as Domino’s best chicken pizza option based on widespread customer enthusiasm, flavor balance, and overall satisfaction ratings. Its perfect blend of spicy, tangy, and creamy elements creates a pizza experience that’s hard to top.

That said, each of the chicken pizzas has its merits:

• Choose the Buffalo Chicken for a spicy, wing-inspired experience
• Go for the Cali Chicken Bacon Ranch when you’re craving something rich and indulgent
• Pick the Memphis BBQ Chicken when you want sweet and tangy flavors
• Try the Chicken Taco Pizza when you’re feeling adventurous

Whatever you choose, Domino’s has proven that chicken pizzas deserve just as much respect as their traditional pepperoni and cheese offerings. And isn’t that what pizza innovation is all about?

Now excuse me while I place an order for a Buffalo Chicken pizza. All this writing has made me hungry!

What’s Your Favorite?

Have you tried all these Domino’s chicken pizzas? Which one tops your personal ranking? Drop a comment below – I’d love to hear your thoughts! And if you’ve got any special customization tips, share those too. The pizza community thanks you!