Pigs are not eaten in various parts of the world, often for religious reasons. What might have caused this aversion?.
As I fly around the world to learn about how pigs are raised in different parts of the world, there is a fairly large area where my planes never touch the ground. This includes North Africa, the Middle East, and what is called South Asia. It goes from Istanbul to Kolkata and from the Sahara to the Caucasus.
Pork is consumed in many cuisines around the world. However, some cultures and religions prohibit eating pork based on ancient taboos and texts. Understanding these pork restrictions provides insight into cultural identities and traditions. In this article, we’ll examine the fascinating history behind the cultures and religions that abstain from pork.
Overview of Pork Avoidance
While pork is widely enjoyed globally, several prominent cultures and faiths forbid consuming it:
-
Judaism has explicit religious bans on pork found in Jewish texts like the Torah and Talmud.
-
Islam also prohibits pork as clearly outlined in the Quran. Eating pork is considered haram or forbidden.
-
Some Christian denominations abstain from pork including Seventh-day Adventists and Ethiopian and Eritrean Orthodox Christians
-
Ancient cultures like the Phoenicians and Syrians had taboos against eating pork.
-
Adherents of more recent spiritual movements like the Hebrew Roots Movement also don’t eat pork.
The reasons behind these pork prohibitions are multifaceted, stemming from health considerations, identity preservation, and animal welfare concerns in addition to religious statutes.
Pork Avoidance in Judaism
The Jewish kosher diet outlined in the Torah and Talmud expressly forbids consuming pork or swine flesh of any kind. Several explanations have been proposed:
-
Pigs were seen as unclean animals that were omnivorous scavengers. Pork was declared non-kosher or treif.
-
Pig farming and pork consumption declined in arid Middle Eastern regions like Judea where pigs were unsustainable livestock.
-
Banning pork may have protected ancient Israelites from trichinosis and other parasites.
-
Abstaining from pork signified Jewish identity and resistance to assimilation and persecution.
As a result, pork has held cultural symbolism for Jews as a boundary marker and display of commitment to Judaism. Yet some secular Jews do include pork while keeping other kosher rules.
Prohibition of Pork in Islam
Islam similarly prohibits pork as something explicitly declared haram or forbidden in the Quran. Consuming pork is thus prohibited for observant Muslims. Possible reasons include:
-
Pigs were considered unhygienic animals in the Arabian desert climate.
-
Concerns about parasites like trichinella in undercooked pork.
-
Pigs compete for scarce resources like food, water and land.
-
Avoiding pork signifies Muslim identity and compliance with Sharia law.
The Quran directly states that pork is haram, so its avoidance is less culturally debated among Muslims compared to Judaism.
Christian Denominations that Abstain from Pork
Some Christian groups also proscribe pork consumption as part of their faith:
-
Seventh-day Adventists avoid unclean meats like pork as part of their healthy lifestyle.
-
Ethiopian Orthodox and Eritrean Orthodox churches prohibit pork as a long-held tradition.
-
Members of Messianic Christian and Hebrew Roots movements also abstain from pork.
For these denominations, pork avoidance is tied to Old Testament scriptures and principles like kosher law. But Christianity has no universal ban on pork present in Judaism and Islam.
Ancient Cultural Taboos Against Pork
Proscriptions against pork predate organized religion in some ancient cultures. Archaeological and textual evidence reveals pork taboos in history:
-
Ancient Syrian and Phoenician texts reference taboos against pigs and pork.
-
Historical accounts suggest the Celtiberians of ancient Iberia avoided pork.
-
Strabo noted that the ancient town of Comana in Pontus prohibited pigs and pork.
-
Pork was taboo in Pessinous in ancient Anatolia according to origin myths.
Scholars propose the pig taboos arose from environmental factors like arid climates and beliefs that pigs were unclean or dangerous animals.
Health Concerns About Consuming Pork
In addition to cultural and religious qualms, there are some legitimate health concerns tied to eating pork:
-
Undercooked pork may transmit parasitic worms like trichinella or tapeworms.
-
Processed pork products like bacon and lunch meat contain sodium nitrites that are carcinogenic.
-
Fatty pork can contribute to inflammation and chronic health conditions.
However, modern farming practices and proper cooking mitigate most of these risks. And there’s no evidence pork is inherently less healthy than other meats.
Cultural Cuisines that Exclude Pork
Cultures that avoid pork have developed rich cuisines without it:
-
Jewish kosher cuisine centers around beef, lamb, chicken, and fish prepared to comply with kosher laws.
-
Halal Muslim cuisine features meat like lamb, chicken, and beef slaughtered according to Islamic guidelines.
-
Ethiopian and Eritrean cuisine offer flavorful vegetarian dishes eaten with spongy injera flatbread.
-
Adventist vegetarian cuisine emphasizes whole grains, legumes, fruits, vegetables, nuts and plant-based proteins like tofu.
So abstaining from pork doesn’t mean sacrificing taste or nutrition for those cultures. Their food traditions offer delicious diversity minus pork.
While pork enjoys popularity globally, many cultures and religions prohibit consuming it for a fascinating mix of reasons – religious statutes, identity preservation, health protection and environmental factors. Understanding these diverse pork abstentions provides insight into cultural values and traditions. So next time you dig into a BLT, consider how the same sandwich could violate deeply-rooted taboos for others. Yet those who eschew pork have still developed rich cuisines showing how prohibitions can drive creativity. In the end, diverse food cultures allow us to approach pork from many thought-provoking angles.
Change of attitude to pork consumption
Somewhere in history, this attitude towards pork must have changed. 2 recently published books made me think of this again. Carel van Schaik, a Dutch biologist at the University of Zurich, Switzerland, had the idea of interpreting the Bible through the eyes of a biologist. Key of his book is that the Bible can be read as ‘the diary of audacious attempts of humanity to learn to deal with the challenges life had to offer’.
He’s talking about the huge changes that happened to humanity as societies that were based on hunters and gatherers slowly turned into early agricultural societies. Often, the benefits of no longer being nomads and farming came with a lot of new challenges, responsibilities, and ways of doing things. In that social and economical context parts of the Bible came into existence, according to the book.
Intensification of pig cultivation
In general, raising pigs began when people started to settle down, which is thought to have happened between 11,000 and 9,000 years ago. Pig farming provided a steady supply of proteins, but they needed a lot of food and water.
Archaeological evidence often shows that substantial amounts of pig bones have been found in excavation sites in Northern Africa and the Middle East. They often date back various thousands of years. Just for example, the builders of the pyramids at Giza, Egypt (2560 BC) had a diverse diet which included pork.
Why billions of people won’t eat pork (or why we don’t know)
FAQ
What race can’t eat pork?
Where does it say not to eat pork?
Why do Muslims not eat pork?
Is pork banned in Israel?
Why do some cultures not eat pork?
These restrictions can vary widely from culture to culture, but one of the most common dietary restrictions is the prohibition of pork. In certain cultures, pork is considered unclean, unhealthy, or even forbidden. In order to understand why certain cultures don’t eat pork, it’s important to consider the cultural background of these societies.
Does Christianity eat pork?
Although christianity is an abrahamic religion, most of its followers do not follow mosaic law and are allowed to consume pork.
Do Indians eat pork?
Muslims do not eat pork, but eat beef. Indians respect each other’s religious sentiments and avoid eating beef or pork, so chicken dishes and lamb dishes are very developed. The animal foods in the Indian diet are mainly derived from goat, lamb, chicken, fish, shrimp and seafood. Many Indians are vegetarians for religious or economic reasons.
Is impossible pork halal or kosher?
Impossible Pork is one such product that is made from plants and not pigs, making it a great option for those who don’t eat conventional ground pork. However, it should be noted that Impossible Pork is not halal or kosher certified. Another alternative meat source for those who don’t eat pork is poultry, such as chicken or turkey.