You may have heard rumors about oysters living in the Great Lakes, but is it true?
We’ll find out the answer to the question “Are there oysters in Lake Michigan?” and learn more about the interesting world of freshwater mussels.
These two-shelled mollusks are an important part of the Great Lakes ecosystem because they live together with fish and change the way water habitats work.
Boasting over 1,600 miles of shoreline, Lake Michigan is a treasured resource providing drinking water, recreation, transportation and livelihoods to millions. As the only Great Lake located entirely within the United States, it holds a special place in the heart of Midwesterners. And when it comes to its food offerings, the lake’s bounty includes prize catches like trout, salmon and whitefish. But are oysters part of Lake Michigan’s aquatic fare? Let’s take a closer look at whether oysters reside in the lake.
A Lake Michigan Primer
Before examining the oyster question specifically, here are some key facts about Lake Michigan:
-
It’s the third largest Great Lake by surface area and second largest by volume. Lake Michigan covers over 22,000 square miles
-
The lake contains 1,180 cubic miles of water and has a shoreline spanning 1,640 miles.
-
The average depth is 279 feet, with the deepest point 925 feet.
-
Major cities along its shores include Chicago, Milwaukee, Green Bay and Muskegon.
-
Commercial fishing, recreational boating, cargo shipping and tourism are major Lake Michigan industries.
-
Lake trout, Chinook salmon, yellow perch and whitefish are popular sport fish species.
-
It connects to Lake Huron via the Straits of Mackinac and ultimately reaches the Atlantic Ocean through the St. Lawrence Seaway.
Now that we have a general lay of the land, let’s focus on whether oysters inhabit its waters.
The Nature of Oysters
Before determining if Lake Michigan supports oysters, it’s helpful to first understand what oysters are and need to thrive.
Oysters are bivalve saltwater mollusks belonging to the ostreidae family. They live in coastal and estuarine waters around the world. As filter feeders, oysters pump water through their gills, filtering out plankton and particles for nourishment.
True oysters flourish in brackish water where saline ocean water and freshwater rivers meet. They attach themselves to hard surfaces on the seafloor using a natural “cement”.
Oysters require specific conditions to survive, including:
- Salinity between 15 to 35 ppt
- Water temperature above freezing
- Calcium-rich water between 7.5 to 8.5 pH
- Hard substrate for anchoring
They are sensitive to changes in their environment. Pollution, sedimentation and ocean acidification can all negatively impact oyster populations.
So could an enormous, freshwater lake like Lake Michigan realistically support true oysters? Let’s dig in.
Lake Michigan’s Suitability for Oysters
At first glance, Lake Michigan falls short of providing ideal oyster habitat. Here are some of the limitations:
-
Lake Michigan is a freshwater lake, with virtually no ocean-derived salinity. Oysters require some salt content.
-
Winter water temperatures drop below 50°F while oysters prefer temperatures above freezing.
-
Lake Michigan lacks “estuarine” conditions where rivers dilute seawater. It’s too fresh.
-
The lake floor offers little hard substrate since it’s mostly sandy and silty. Oysters need firm anchoring.
-
pH is around 8, slightly above the ideal range. Acidification could threaten oysters.
-
Pollution from agricultural runoff, urban areas and industry degrades water quality.
-
Invasive mussels like zebra and quagga mussels compete with native shellfish.
Based on these factors, marine biologists agree that Lake Michigan lacks the basics needed to support oysters as found in their native coastal habitats. The conditions are far too fresh and frigid for the briny bivalves.
Native “Oysters” in Lake Michigan
While actual oysters don’t reside in Lake Michigan, there is a native mollusk that early settlers nicknamed “the oyster of Lake Michigan.”
This nickname refers to the threeridge mussel, a freshwater mollusk abundant in the lake. Resembling an oversized clam, threeridge mussels can reach 6 inches long. They earned their name from the three parallel ridges along their dark brown shells.
Early French explorers and fur traders noted the abundance of threeridge mussels in Lake Michigan and across North America. Their firm white meat has a mild oyster-like taste and texture when cooked.
Indigenous peoples like the Potawatomi and Ottawa tribes traditionally used the shells of the threeridge mussel for tools and jewelry. Later European settlers collected and sold the shells for button-making.
So while true oysters don’t inhabit Lake Michigan, the threeridge mussel has an equally important place in the history and ecology of the region. Unfortunately, pollution, invasive species and habitat loss threaten the survival of this unique “oyster” today.
Ecological Role of Native Mussels
Beyond their historical connection, freshwater mussels like the threeridge play a valuable ecological role that is often overlooked. Here’s a glimpse of their importance:
-
As filter feeders, they help clean billions of gallons of lake water. This improves clarity and water quality.
-
Mussel beds stabilize soft lake floor sediments and shorelines against erosion.
-
They recycle nutrients, releasing them back into the ecosystem for algae and aquatic plants.
-
Mussel shells, alive or dead, provide critical fish habitat and refuge for small invertebrates.
-
Mussels have a symbiotic relationship with certain fish species during their larval stage, giving them an advantage for survival.
Protecting native Lake Michigan mussels helps maintain balance and biodiversity. Allowing this keystone species to disappear would have far-reaching impacts across the food web.
Future Outlook
Looking ahead, experts consider it highly unlikely oysters could ever inhabit Lake Michigan. Even with climate change warming the planet, the lake is simply too far from an oceanic salt source. Cooler temperatures and insufficient calcium also preclude true oysters settling in.
However, there are efforts underway to protect and restore native mussels back to healthy population levels. Removing dams, controlling invasive species, limiting pollution, and protecting shorelines and spawning habitat all contribute to freshwater mussel conservation.
The ecological health of the Great Lakes depends on preserving native species like the threeridge mussel. Although Lake Michigan will never host true oysters, appreciating its unique mollusks and their role in history is an essential part of protecting the lake’s future. The threeridge is a living treasure that tells the story of Lake Michigan’s past and reminds us of its vulnerability.
The Difference Between Oysters And Freshwater Mussels
While both oysters and freshwater mussels are bivalve mollusks, there are significant differences between the two. Oysters are exclusively found in saltwater habitats, whereas freshwater mussels inhabit freshwater environments. The shells of freshwater mussels are thin and smooth, while the shells of oysters are rougher and thicker, more irregular.
Another important difference is that oysters eat plankton and other tiny organisms in the water, which is called “filter feeding.” Freshwater mussels, on the other hand, stay in one place and filter feed by passing water through their gills. They get nutrients from the water column.
Furthermore, oysters are considered a delicacy and are often consumed raw or cooked in various dishes. Freshwater mussels, however, are not typically consumed by humans due to their tough texture and unappetizing taste.
In terms of ecological importance, both oysters and freshwater mussels play crucial roles in their respective habitats. Marine animals that live in reefs depend on oysters for their homes, and freshwater mussels help keep the water clean by filtering out nutrients and pollutants.
The History Of Oysters In The Great Lakes
Oysters have been around in the Great Lakes area for a long time. In the 1600s, European settlers said that huge oyster reefs made it dangerous for ships to navigate. Back then, oysters were picked with hand tongs. By the 1800s, dredges were also used. In the 1850s, more than 1. Every year, 5 million bushels of oysters were taken from the Bay. After 30 years, that number had grown to 20 million.
The oyster fishery in the Bay was one of the most important in the United States by the early 1900s. But too much harvesting took away a lot of oysters from the Bay and killed off the reefs that were there before. These reefs were scraped away during the dredging process. Now, oyster beds are mostly made up of flat, thin layers of dead shell and live oysters spread out over the bottom of the Bay. These damaged habitats have less surface area for animals that live in reefs to live on and are easy for sediment to cover.
Even though oyster populations were going down, oysters were still a popular food in the Great Lakes area. From the East Coast, most likely Long Island, they came by boat through the Great Lakes and the Erie Canal. The oysters were kept live and packed in sawdust throughout the journey.
It is still possible to find oysters in Lake Michigan, but they are not naturally there. Instead, they are likely remnants of past human activity or have been introduced through ballast water from ships. Even though there aren’t as many as there used to be, those who find them can still get a taste of history.