Recommendations are independently chosen by Revieweds editors. Purchases made through the links below may earn us and our publishing partners a commission.
Recently, on my way to the register at my local Trader Joe’s, I saw buckets of beautiful white tulips that were on sale for $6 for ten. 99.
It’s not often that I buy flowers, but the tulips seemed like a good idea since I had guests over for dinner and my yard wasn’t full of flowers.
Five of the stems went limp when I cut open the plastic bag for the tulips at home. These poor, beautiful things couldn’t be saved, and they fell around the vase’s edge like tired ballerinas.
I’ve been shopping at Trader Joe’s regularly for more than two decades—a span spread across three different cities. I won’t buy some things anywhere else because I think TJs has the best value and quality. They can be very helpful for people who live in smaller cities where it may be hard to find ethnic foods. And Consumer Reports ranks Trader Joe’s highest of all national chains in terms of customer satisfaction. Arriving home and discovering you have a shoddy product is a real bummer.
But not everything at Trader Joe’s is a dream buy. Though often temptingly packaged, there are a few categories I’ve learned to avoid.
In the company’s defense, store managers are given latitude to refund or replace products without question. But if you’re counting on something for tonight’s dinner, like the tulips for my table, getting home and finding a bad product is a real letdown.
Tilapia has become an increasingly popular fish option for many consumers looking for an affordable, mild-tasting white fish. Trader Joe’s sells tilapia fillets in the frozen section that provide a convenient and budget-friendly way to enjoy this lean protein. But is Trader Joe’s tilapia safe to eat? Let’s take a closer look at the pros and cons of choosing this product.
An Overview of Tilapia
Tilapia is one of the most widely farmed fish in the world. Native to Africa tilapia are hardy fish that can thrive in fish farming operations. Most tilapia sold commercially in the United States is raised in fish farms in Latin America and Asia.
Some key facts about tilapia
-
Tilapia is an inexpensive fish, typically costing $3-5 per pound. It’s much more budget-friendly than options like salmon or sole
-
It has a mild, neutral flavor that takes on the flavors of whatever it’s cooked with.
-
Tilapia is a lean, white fish. A 3 ounce serving contains about 26 grams of protein with around 3 grams of fat.
-
It’s considered a sustainable seafood choice since it’s efficiently raised in fish farms rather than wild caught. However, some environmental concerns have been raised regarding tilapia farming practices.
Evaluating Trader Joe’s Tilapia
Trader Joe’s sells frozen tilapia fillets for $5.99 per pound. Here are some things to consider about this specific product:
Pros:
-
Good price point compared to fresh tilapia from the fish counter
-
Individually wrapped fillets are frozen right after harvesting for freshness
-
Firm texture holds up well to cooking methods like pan frying or baking
-
Mild flavor takes on spices, herbs and sauces added during cooking
Potential cons:
-
Variability in vacuum seal tightness. Some packages not sealed well, leading to potential freezer burn.
-
Dark bloodline may be unappealing visually. Fillets can be cut in half to remove.
-
Lack of traceability regarding where tilapia is farmed.
Overall, Trader Joe’s tilapia offers an affordable frozen fish option compared to pricier seafood like salmon or cod. However, there are a few areas for improvement to maximize freshness and quality.
Evaluating the Safety of Trader Joe’s Tilapia
When examining the safety of any seafood product, there are a few key factors to consider:
Freshness
-
Is the seafood processed and frozen shortly after harvest?
-
Does the packaging protect quality and prevent freezer burn?
Trader Joe’s tilapia is processed soon after harvest. However, vacuum seal tightness is sometimes inconsistent.
Purity
-
Does it contain contaminants like mercury, plastic or other pollutants?
-
Is it treated with any unnecessary additives?
Tilapia is not known to contain high mercury levels and Trader Joe’s version contains no additives. However, it’s unclear where the tilapia is farmed.
Sanitation
-
Are processing facilities following food safety protocols?
-
Could bacterial contamination occur during processing, storage or handling?
Trader Joe’s has strong food safety standards. Proper cooking should kill any bacteria present.
Nutrition
-
Is it a nutritious option providing protein, healthy fats and other nutrients?
-
Are there any nutritional downsides?
Tilapia is highly nutritious and lean. No major nutritional drawbacks.
Based on these factors, Trader Joe’s tilapia appears to be a reasonably safe choice, especially when properly cooked. There are no major red flags, but stricter quality controls could enhance freshness and purity.
Tips for Picking and Preparing Trader Joe’s Tilapia
Here are some recommendations for choosing and cooking Trader Joe’s frozen tilapia fillets:
-
Inspect packaging – Avoid torn or poorly sealed packages which can cause freezer burn.
-
Use within 3-4 months – For maximum freshness, use frozen tilapia within a few months of purchasing.
-
Thaw properly – Thaw fillets overnight in the fridge or immerse sealed package in cold water. Don’t thaw at room temp.
-
Cook thoroughly – Cook to an internal temperature of 145°F. Tilapia cooks fast – just 2-3 minutes per side when pan searing.
-
Flavor it up – Tilapia tastes bland on its own. Jazz it up with bold spices, lemon, garlic, herbs and sauces.
-
Remove bloodline – The dark red bloodline isn’t unsafe but can be unappetizing. Simply cut each fillet in half horizontally before cooking.
Health Benefits of Eating Tilapia
Adding tilapia to your diet provides several important health perks:
-
High in protein – A 3 ounce serving contains 26 grams of protein to support muscle growth and satisfy hunger.
-
Low in calories – With just 110 calories in a 3 ounce cooked portion, it fits into any diet.
-
Rich in B-vitamins – Tilapia provides niacin, vitamin B12 and other essential B-vitamins.
-
Good source of potassium and phosphorus – These minerals boost bone health.
-
Heart healthy fats – The omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids in tilapia promote heart health.
-
Low mercury levels – Unlike some fish, tilapia is low on the food chain so mercury accumulation is minimal.
Is Trader Joe’s Tilapia Worth Buying?
Trader Joe’s frozen tilapia fillets offer an affordable, convenient way to incorporate this nutritious and lean fish into your diet. The tilapia at Trader Joe’s appears to be reasonably safe when properly handled and cooked. While not the highest quality tilapia on the market, it provides good value for the price.
To maximize freshness and quality, carefully inspect packaging, use frozen fillets soon after purchasing, and take steps like removing the bloodline and seasoning the mild fish. Keeping frozen tilapia on hand provides a quick, budget-friendly way to get a lean, protein-packed meal on the table any night of the week.
So is Trader Joe’s tilapia safe to eat? Overall, yes – it’s a nutritious fish that can be part of a healthy diet when bought fresh and prepared properly. With a few minor drawbacks, Trader Joe’s tilapia earns its place as an affordable and convenient seafood staple for health-conscious shoppers.
Fresh Seafood and Sushi
A few years ago, Trader Joe’s earned a black eye from seafood watchdogs for selling seafood that was not sustainably sourced. Today, the chain gets a thumbs-up on the Greenpeace scorecard among retailers for its sales practices.
Though sustainably sourced, overall quality of Trader Joes seafood is unreliable.
But I don’t find a lot of the fresh seafood at Trader Joe’s to be appealing. I’ve had salmon caught in the ocean that tasted cloudy, scallops that were soaked in water, and sushi that was full of fake fish and other non-Japanese ingredients. “Sell-by” dates are often meaningless.
With the fish being sealed in plastic and no one at the fish counter to talk to, we never know where or when the fish came from. You won’t find any sales when a big shipment comes in like you would at Whole Foods, Wegmans, or Sprouts. Again, the same goes for fresh meats. However, I trust Trader Joe’s beef, lamb, and chicken more. You won’t find any sales when a big shipment comes in like you would at Whole Foods, Wegmans, or Sprouts.
That said, I don’t avoid most of the frozen or canned seafood items sold at Trader Joe’s. The frozen tilapia fillets are a great deal at $6.99 a pound, and the chain deserves praise for its affordably priced, canned skipjack tuna, sustainably caught through pole and line fishing.
Fresh Fruits and Vegetables
Fresh fruits and vegetables are now available at most stores in the chain, even though they weren’t there when I first started shopping there. But, as I’ve learned more often than I’d like to say, a lot of the food at Trader Joe’s is obviously flawed, and almost none of it comes from nearby farms.
Excess packaging often conceals the quality of produce at Trader Joes.
To begin, the quality isn’t always good. Tomatoes that don’t taste good, peaches that are rock hard, and blackberries that are moldy show up more often than they should. The products often spoil faster than the same items bought elsewhere. Problems that might normally be detected by simply examining the items are often masked within the packaging. Also, the packaging is too much—most of the food is in plastic clamshells or trays, which means that these items are sold with a bigger environmental impact than they need to have.
Even though Trader Joe’s is known for having great deals, some of the food is either too expensive or needs to be bought in too large of quantities. The price per pound for zucchini might be fair, but who needs five at once unless they’re making zucchini bread? Also, $1 for two small garlic bulbs in a package? 29 is a scam because at most regular supermarkets you can get two or three times as many for the same price. Even though Trader Joe’s is known for having great deals, some of the food is either too expensive or needs to be bought in too large of quantities.
Trader Joe’s keeps its checkout lines moving faster by selling items in units instead of pounds. This is because there is no need for scales to weigh produce. But the business should give these cost savings to customers (this happens more often at Costco, by the way).
Still, there are exceptions. Bagged, pre-washed salad greens seem as tasty and fresh as what I get elsewhere. Some items are only available during certain times of the year and are of good quality and value. One week it might be globe artichokes and the next week it might be ears of corn. And at just 19 cents apiece, the bananas are a loss leader I never pass up.
Trader Joe’s Top 10 Things To Buy In 2023
FAQ
What is the safest tilapia to eat?
How can you tell if tilapia is safe to eat?
Does Trader Joe’s carry tilapia?
Is Sam’s Club tilapia safe to eat?
Is tilapia safe to eat?
Tilapia contains beneficial nutrients. But depending on where the fish is sourced from, there may be a higher risk of safety concerns, including bacterial contamination. Tilapia is an inexpensive, mild-flavored fish. It is the fourth most commonly consumed type of seafood in the United States.
Should you buy tilapia?
It’s a good idea to know where your fish is coming from and make an informed shopping decision. And rotate the type of fish you buy so that you get a good dose of omega-3s and do right environmentally. Just remember, tilapia once a week is still a healthier choice than a cheeseburger and fries.
Where to eat tilapia?
The best tilapia is raised in Peru and Ecuador in raceways—shallow tanks with flowing water—and freshwater ponds, according to Monterey Bay Aquarium Seafood Watch. Other good choices: Fish raised in Taiwan, Mexico, and Indonesia. You should avoid consuming tilapia raised in China, according to the group.
Is tilapia a healthy fish?
Tilapia is an inexpensive, commonly consumed fish that is farmed all over the world. It is a lean source of protein that is also high in several vitamins and minerals, such as selenium, vitamin B12, niacin and potassium. However, there are several reasons why you may want to avoid or limit tilapia.