One of the best things about a traditional New England lobster dinner is how simple it is to make. No complicated sauces, no fancy techniques, no need to fire up the oven on a hot day. And you need only one pot. But just because it’s simple doesn’t mean that you can’t run into trouble. In fact, because this is such an elemental meal, it’s important to get the details right. Mostly, that means cooking your lobster the right way. Here are five of the most common mistakes in cooking lobster, and how to avoid them.
Lobster is one of the most iconic and delicious seafood dishes. With its bright red shell and succulent white meat, lobster is a luxury food item that is synonymous with indulgence and special occasions. But if you’ve ever bitten into a juicy lobster tail or cracked open a lobster claw, you may have noticed something – lobster has a distinctly salty flavor.
Where does all that saltiness come from? As it turns out, there are several reasons why lobster can taste quite salty compared to other types of seafood or meat. In this article, we’ll explore the science and biology behind why lobster is so salty.
Lobsters Live in Saltwater Environments
The most obvious reason lobster tastes salty is that lobsters live in saltwater habitats like the Atlantic Ocean Anything that lives in salt water will absorb some of that salty flavor into their body and flesh. Saltwater fish like tuna, cod, and halibut also often have a briny flavor for the same reason.
Lobsters are marine crustaceans that live on rocky, sandy, or muddy bottoms of the ocean floor. They are abundant in the North Atlantic ocean along the New England coast and Canada, where the chilly water has high salinity. Caribbean lobsters live in warmer tropical waters, but these habitats are still quite salty.
Since lobsters live, breathe, eat, and grow surrounded by ocean water, it makes sense that all that salt seeps into their tissue and cells This gives their meat a naturally salty seafood taste when cooked.
Saltiness Varies Between Locations
However, not all lobster meat tastes equally as salty. There can be subtle variations in flavor and saltiness depending on where the lobster originated.
-
New England lobster tends to be the most iconic and sought-after. The cold North Atlantic waters have a higher natural salinity, which gets absorbed by the lobster. New England lobster is renowned for its hearty salty flavor.
-
Caribbean spiny lobster comes from the warm tropical waters of the Caribbean Sea, Florida coast, and Gulf of Mexico. This water generally has a lower salinity, so Caribbean spiny lobster meat often has a slightly milder, less salty flavor
-
California spiny lobster and South African lobster live in the Pacific Ocean and South Atlantic Ocean, respectively. Their flavor profiles fall somewhere in between New England and Caribbean lobster.
So a lobster caught in Maine may taste saltier than one caught in the Bahamas based on differences in their native ocean habitats. Where the lobster originated impacts just how intensely salty it will taste.
Boiling and Cooking Methods Enhance Saltiness
Another factor impacting the saltiness of lobster meat is how it is prepared and cooked. The most common cooking methods for lobster involve boiling or steaming it while it is still alive moments before eating.
For boiling especially, chefs add salt directly to the cooking liquid. This seasoning later penetrates the lobster meat during cooking. The salty water acts like a brine and boosts the natural saltiness of the lobster.
Using ocean water or water with sea salt will make the lobster boil even more salty. The amount of seasoning used in the cooking process can really amplify or reduce the final salty flavor in the lobster meat.
Other cooking techniques like grilling, broiling, or baking lobster meat use little or no salt. These methods allow the natural mild sweetness of lobster to come through instead of the briny saltiness.
Salt Helps Preserve Canned and Frozen Lobster
Another time you may notice very salty lobster meat is when eating processed lobster products like canned lobster meat or frozen lobster tails.
The high sodium content of canned and frozen lobster helps preserve the shelf life and quality during storage and transportation. Salt lowers the ability of bacteria to grow, keeping the lobster safe to eat for months.
Of course, all that excess salt also impacts the flavor – canned and frozen lobster often has a very pronounced salty flavor. Always rinse off canned lobster before eating to remove some of the sodium and saltiness.
Saltiness Equates to Quality and Freshness
While saltiness in lobster meat has biological causes, there is also a psychological factor at play. For many seafood fans, a noticeable saltiness is desirable and indicates high quality.
The salty taste of ocean brininess is associated with fresh, delicious seafood. When tasting a milder, less salty lobster, some assume it is not as fresh or flavorful.
This phenomenon extends beyond just lobster to include sophisticated offerings like oysters, caviar, and sashimi. A light saltiness satisfies our expectation of what gourmet seafood should taste like.
So while subtle differences in lobster habitat and preparation affect salt content, a mildly salty flavor is generally a sign of prime lobster. It develops a pleasant balance of briny and sweet flavors.
Tips for Controlling Lobster Saltiness
If you find lobster to be too salty for your tastes, there are a few handy tips to help tame the saltiness:
-
Soak lobster meat in fresh water or milk for 30 minutes before cooking to draw out excess salt.
-
Opt for steaming or baking instead of boiling to avoid absorbing additional salt.
-
Skip the salt in any recipe seasonings to let the natural sweetness shine through.
-
Order spiny lobster like Caribbean lobster which has a milder salinity.
-
Request lobster rolls or lobster salad made with mayonnaise and lemon which provide a tangy contrast to salt.
-
Drink something acidic like lemonade or white wine to help cut through the saltiness.
While lobster will always have a hint of salty ocean flavor, you can control just how salty your serving tastes. Follow these suggestions to make sure your next lobster dinner achieves the perfect balance of salty and sweet.
The Verdict on Lobster’s Saltiness
Lobster has an undeniably salty flavor that sets it apart from other proteins. The combination of living in saltwater, getting boiled in seasoned water, and salt-preserved processing leads to a noticeable salt-forward taste. Choosing lobster’s origin and cooking method allow you to influence how salty it ultimately turns out.
For many seafood aficionados, the moderate saltiness of lobster is half the appeal. It provides that taste of the sea that makes lobster so crave-worthy. The salty flavor complements the natural sweetness of the flesh for a multidimensional burst of flavor in each bite.
So next time you crack open a lobster tail and savor the tender meat inside, appreciate the complex science behind that salty taste. Lobster’s saltiness might make you thirsty, but it’s also what makes this expensive shellfish such a legendary seafood treat worth savoring.
5 Mistakes to Avoid When Cooking Lobster
- It will take 8 to 12 minutes to boil lobsters that are about 1 to 1½ pounds in weight.
- It takes 9 to 12 minutes to steam lobsters of average size, but it depends on how big they are.
- If you can find soft-shell lobsters in the summer, cook them for two to three minutes less than if you could find hard-shell lobsters in the winter.
Big Mistakes Everyone Makes When Cooking Lobster
FAQ
Why does lobster taste salty?
Does lobster have a lot of salt?
Are lobsters healthy to eat?
Why is lobster meat so tasty?