The truth is that marbling, or the fat inside the muscles of beef, can be very different from one animal to the next depending on its health and diet over its lifetime. Grain-fed and grass-fed fat are different.
Take a look at the different kinds of beef there are in your grocery store. You can tell the difference between conventional beef from the butcher, which comes from grain-fed cows, and grass-fed beef by the way they look. Grass-fed and grain-fed cattle look very different when you put them next to each other. There are a lot of false beliefs about how we think about beef quality. You might think one is healthier than the other or even that one just looks healthier. One of them is the way we think about the color of fat on our steaks. We took a deeper look at this, specifically, why the fat on grain-fed vs. grass-fed looks so different.
There are a few main differences. One of the most obvious ones is the color of the fat. If a cow is fed grains, its fat will be very white. If it is fed grass, its fat will be off white, almost yellowish white. Here’s a fun way to see how much you know about beef: just look at a cut! The pigment beta-carotene is what makes the meat change color. Since it’s found in grass, cows that eat a lot of nutrient-dense grasses will have less white fat. Beta Carotene also gives cattle an abundant source of vitamin A. If they are eating the grass year-round, they will be getting their vitamins easily with every meal. During the winter, cattle that are grass-fed or grass-fed and finished but not pasture-raised all year may need extra vitamin A. In places where it doesn’t get warm enough to grow pasture all year, cattle are fed grain or dried grasses during the winter. The fat in those cattle will also break down more easily when you cook them because they only eat grass. This means a more tender and buttery bite. It’s more likely that the fat in the steak will be tougher if the cattle were fed grain or grain with other feed.
Have you ever noticed that some beef has yellowish fat instead of the usual white fat? This natural variation in fat color is actually very common and can tell you a lot about how the cattle were raised. In this article, we’ll explain what causes yellow fat on beef and what it means about the beef’s quality and nutritional value
Why Beef Fat Can Be Yellow
Beef fat turns yellow when cattle eat large amounts of green forage and grass. Green plants contain high levels of carotenoids—the same pigments that give carrots and certain other fruits and vegetables their orange color. When cattle eat green forage, these carotenoids are absorbed into their fat tissue, causing the white fat to take on a yellowish hue.
The main carotenoid responsible for yellow fat in cattle is called beta-carotene. As cattle graze on fresh pasture and grass, the beta-carotene accumulates in their fat. Some cattle store more of this pigment than others due to genetic factors but in general, cattle with the yellowest fat have been grazing on green forage for an extended period of time.
Yellow Fat Indicates Grass-Fed Beef
Because fresh pasture is the primary source of yellow pigments in beef, yellow fat is a clear indicator that the cattle were grass-fed. Beef with yellow fat typically comes from cattle that have grazed on green grass for most or all of their lives, as opposed to being fattened up on grain in a feedlot.
So when you see beef with distinctly yellow fat in the grocery store, it means you’re looking at meat from grass-fed cattle. The yellow color tells you that the cattle lived outdoors on pasture and ate a natural, grass-based diet—not an artificial feedlot diet of grain, corn, and soy.
Nutritional Differences in Grass-Fed Beef
From a nutritional standpoint, grass-fed beef with yellow fat differs from conventional grain-fed beef in a few key ways:
-
Higher in antioxidants Grass-fed beef contains higher levels of antioxidant carotenoids like beta-carotene These compounds have been linked to a reduced risk of certain cancers and other health benefits
-
Higher in omega-3s: Meat from cattle raised on fresh pasture contains higher concentrations of beneficial omega-3 fatty acids compared to grain-fed beef. Omega-3s have anti-inflammatory properties.
-
Lower in saturated fat: Beef from grass-fed cattle often contains slightly less total fat than grain-fed beef, and a higher portion of unsaturated fat. This makes grass-fed slightly healthier for heart health.
-
Higher in CLA: Grass-fed beef is higher in conjugated linoleic acid (CLA), a type of fatty acid associated with fat loss and cancer prevention.
So in terms of nutritional profile, grass-fed beef with yellow fat beats out conventional beef in several ways. The yellow color acts as your guide to finding beef from cattle that lived a natural lifestyle and ate the diet they evolved to eat.
Grass-Fed Flavor
In addition to superior nutrition, many people find that grass-fed beef simply tastes better. The flavors are often described as grassier, earthier, and richer than conventional grain-fed beef. This comes down to the differences in diet.
Cattle fed a controlled grain diet in a feedlot tend to produce beef with a milder, more generic flavor. But cattle eating a diverse diet of grasses and plants on open pasture produce more complex, nuanced flavors in their meat. Their beef tastes like the grasses and herbs they grazed on.
So when you bite into a tender grass-fed steak with yellow fat, you’re tasting the flavors of the fields and pastures where the cattle were raised. It’s a window into the natural flavors of the land.
Is Yellow Fat Less Healthy?
With beef fat, darker color doesn’t mean lower quality. Some people wrongly assume that yellow fat on beef means the meat is less healthy or nutritious. But the exact opposite is true—the yellow color comes from beneficial antioxidants, and indicates healthier grass-fed meat.
The yellow hue in beef fat doesn’t mean the animal was sick or that the meat is inferior. In fact, it provides an easily identifiable marker that the beef you’re buying comes from cattle that lived a natural lifestyle. So seek out packages of beef with the richest yellow fat you can find!
Marbling in Grass-Fed Beef
When evaluating beef quality, most people look for ample marbling (thin white lines of fat running through the meat). Marbling adds flavor and tenderness. Grass-fed beef is sometimes criticized for having less marbling compared to grain-fed beef.
It’s true that cattle raised exclusively on pasture may have slightly less marbling in their beef. But ideally, grass-fed cattle are finished on a balanced ration that includes supplemental feeds like hay, silage, or grain. This helps them develop marbling levels that rival grain-fed beef.
With the right finishing methods, grass-fed cattle can produce beef with excellent marbling while still retaining the yellow fat that indicates a healthy, natural diet. Look for beef that combines good marbling with distinctly yellow external fat. This signifies great flavor and tenderness from a grass-fed animal.
Summary of Key Points
To wrap up, here are the key takeaways on what yellow color in beef fat indicates:
-
Yellow fat comes from carotenoids in fresh forage and grass the cattle ate. It shows the cattle were grass-fed.
-
Grass-fed beef is higher in antioxidants, omega-3s, and CLA compared to grain-fed beef.
-
Grass-fed beef has a more complex, robust flavor than grain-fed.
-
Yellow fat does NOT mean the beef is unhealthy or inferior. It’s the opposite—a sign of better nutrition.
-
With the right diet, grass-fed cattle can have good marbling while retaining yellow fat.
So don’t be deterred by yellow fat on beef—embrace it! It means you’re getting nutritious, flavorful meat from cattle that lived a natural lifestyle. The next time you spot a grass-fed steak with rich yellow fat marbling, grab it up for a delicious and healthy meal.
Here’s The Fat (color) Truth breakdown:
- Yellow-white in color
- Beta-carotene, which is found in grass, gives it its yellow color.
- Beta-Carotene is a great source of Vitamin A.
- If the cattle are raised on pasture all year, they get a lot of Vitamin A.
- Fat isn’t as hard, so it melts or breaks down more easily when it’s cooked.
- White in color.
- Minimal Beta-Carotene.
- Animals often need to have supplements of Vitamin A.
- When you cook, fat doesn’t break down as much because it is much tougher.
Before it’s sold, all of our beef is 100% grass-fed and finished because the climates where we get our cattle allow them to graze on grass all year. Thats why our fat color in our beef is not bright white like grain-fed beef.
When you buy beef in the future, pay more attention to the fat. It can tell you more about the animal’s life. Fat color does not lie. Now that you know more about Fat Truth, you can choose the best products for your diet and goals.
Yellow Fat on Grassfed Beef – Is Something Wrong with It?
FAQ
What is the yellow fat in a butchered cow?
Why is my beef tallow yellow?
Why is Jersey beef fat yellow?