Before Thanksgiving, you should not use this one tool in the kitchen. It will help you cook the best turkey. Ironically, it’s the pop-up turkey timer.
As far as kitchen tools go, the pop-up turkey timer that comes with store-bought birds is probably the least reliable of all time. By the time the timer does actually pop, your turkey will be overcooked and as dry as sawdust. Advertisement.
That’s because commercial turkey buttons are set to pop at 180 to 185 degrees Fahrenheit, but you should take the turkey out of the oven when it reaches 160 degrees F. Its temperature will continue to rise as it rests on the counter, reaching the 165 degrees Fahrenheit that the FDA recommends. If you use a pop-up timer, you end up drastically overcooking your turkey.
The pop-up timer that comes pre-inserted in store-bought turkeys has been a staple of Thanksgiving cooking for generations This ingenious device is designed to pop up when the turkey reaches the ideal internal temperature, supposedly eliminating the guesswork around cooking times. But how accurate are these timers really? Can they be trusted to ensure a perfectly cooked turkey? I decided to dig into the controversy around pop-up timers to find out.
A Convenient Solution…Or Is It?
The pop-up timer seems like an ideal solution for roasting turkey. Inserted near the breastbone of the raw bird, it’s meant to pop up when the turkey reaches 165°F, the safe minimum internal temperature. This removes the need to repeatedly check temps with a meat thermometer. Just wait for the pop, then immediately remove the turkey from the oven. So convenient!
But over the years, pop-up timers have developed a reputation for being wildly inaccurate and unreliable. Stories of lackluster pops hours after the turkey is woefully overcooked or no pop at all are commonplace.
Understandably, this has led many home cooks to distrust this once-ingenious technology. Most experts now recommend ignoring pop-up timers entirely and using a trusty meat thermometer instead
But are pop-up timers really so inaccurate? I decided to dig into some actual testing data to find out
In Testing, Pop-Up Timers ranged from 139°F to Over 165°F
Consumer Reports conducted thorough testing on pop-up turkey timers to assess their accuracy. They tested 21 different timers from various brands, including timers inserted by the processor and timers purchased separately and inserted by the user.
The results showed huge variation in pop-up temperatures, ranging from 139.5°F on the low end to well over 165°F on the high end.
The 139.5°F reading is dangerously low, as poultry is only considered safe at 165°F minimum. This means some timers popped while the turkey was still undercooked and unsafe to eat.
On the other end of the spectrum, many timers didn’t pop until 10-15 degrees over the 165°F target. This leads to dry, overcooked turkey.
Overall, most timers did eventually pop between 160-170°F. But the wide range and variability makes it clear you can’t rely on pop-up timers alone to gauge doneness and safety.
Why Are Pop-Up Timers So Inaccurate?
With all the modern technology available, it may seem surprising that these timers remain so unreliable. Here are some of the factors impacting accuracy:
-
Placement – The timer needs to be centrally located to work properly. If it’s near a bone or tucked into uneven meat, it won’t pop accurately.
-
Cooking method – Pop-up timers are designed for standard roasting. Convection ovens, frying, or smoking can affect the timing.
-
Temperature variations – Even in a standard oven, hot and cool spots can make the breast and thighs cook unevenly.
-
Turkey size and shape – Pop-up timers are calibrated for standard sizes. Very large or small turkeys will throw off the timing.
-
Type of timer – Third-party timers inserted by the user tend to be less accurate than pre-inserted varieties.
While the technology has improved, even the best pop-up timers have a margin of error around 10 degrees. For optimal safety and quality, they shouldn’t be relied on alone.
For Best Results, Use a Meat Thermometer
The consensus among cooking experts is that pop-up timers should never be solely trusted. For the most reliable results, use these timers only as a visual cue to start periodically checking the turkey’s temp.
Insert an instant-read thermometer into the thickest part of the breast, thigh, and wing, checking the temps regularly as the turkey cooks. Cook until the breast and thighs reach 165°F minimum.
For even easier monitoring, use a wireless leave-in thermometer. The probe stays in the meat the entire time, transmitting the temp to a base unit or your phone. This removes the need to continually open the oven.
While pop-up timers can provide a helpful ballpark gauge, only a thermometer can confirm the turkey has reached a safe final temperature throughout. Don’t rely solely on the pop – let your thermometer have the final say for foolproof holiday cooking.
Here’s how turkey timers actually work.
Inside a standard pop-up turkey timer, there’s a red plastic indicator stick that sits in a plastic casing. The stick has a spring wrapped around it. The soft metal in the tip warms as the turkey roasts and eventually melts at around 180 degrees F. Then the red stick is released from the metal and the spring makes it pop up. That’s 15 degrees higher than the recommended 165, making your turkey extremely dry.Advertisement
From Our Partners
Everything Thanksgiving: Get all our Thanksgiving recipes, how-to’s and more!
Before Thanksgiving, you should not use this one tool in the kitchen. It will help you cook the best turkey. Ironically, it’s the pop-up turkey timer.
As far as kitchen tools go, the pop-up turkey timer that comes with store-bought birds is probably the least reliable of all time. By the time the timer does actually pop, your turkey will be overcooked and as dry as sawdust. Advertisement.
That’s because commercial turkey buttons are set to pop at 180 to 185 degrees Fahrenheit, even though you should actually remove the turkey from the oven when it reaches 160 degrees F (then you temperature will continue rising as it rests on the counter, to the FDA-recommended 165 degrees Fahrenheit). If you use a pop-up timer, you end up drastically overcooking your turkey.
How to Use the Pop-Up Timer in Your Turkey
FAQ
Can you trust the pop-up timer in a turkey?
At what temperature does a turkey timer pop?
Why hasn’t my turkey popped?
How accurate is the turkey popper on Reddit?
Are Turkey pop-up timers accurate?
Turkey pop-up timers are a convenient way to ensure that your turkey is cooked to perfection. However, it is important to note that turkey pop-up timers are not always accurate, so it is still important to check the internal temperature of the turkey with a meat thermometer to make sure that it is cooked to the desired doneness.
Are pop-up timers accurate?
1. They can be inaccurate. Turkey cooking pop-up timers are not always accurate. The temperature at which the turkey is cooked, the size of the turkey, and the cooking method can all affect how long it takes for the turkey to cook. As a result, the pop-up timer may not go off at the same time for every turkey.
What is a pop-up Turkey timer?
The pop-up turkey timer, also known as a popper, is a handy little device included with most store-bought turkeys to help determine doneness. It’s designed to pop up when the turkey reaches the ideal internal temperature, taking the guesswork out of cook times. But just how accurate and reliable are these pop-up turkey timers really?
What temperature does a Turkey pop-up timer pop up?
The temperature at which the turkey pop-up timer pops up varies depending on the brand of the timer. Some timers pop up at 165 degrees Fahrenheit, while others pop up at 180 degrees Fahrenheit. It is important to check the manufacturer’s instructions to determine the correct temperature for your turkey pop-up timer.
Can a pop-up timer burn a Turkey?
Turkey cooking pop-up timers are made of metal, which can become hot during cooking. If you touch the timer while it is in the oven, you could burn yourself. Additionally, if the timer falls into the turkey, it could cause a fire. 3. They can be difficult to remove. Once the turkey is cooked, the pop-up timer can be difficult to remove.
Does a pop-up timer really work for Thanksgiving turkeys?
For decades, one purported solution to this holiday hassle has been the pop-up timer that comes with some birds, a device invented to take the uncertainty out of poultry cooking times, especially for Thanksgiving turkeys.